Gender and Family in Early Christianity
REL 332 OTTO
SPRING 2014 M-6
MWF 1:00-1:50 P.M.


Description of Course

A study of the Greco-Roman family life; early Christian moral teachings in the context of Jewish and Greco-Roman popular morality; the early Christian family with a focus on slaves and children, marriage and divorce; gender constructions of masculinity and homosexual behavior and the position of women in the early church.

What were the "family values" of the first Christians? What were their ethics and moral teachings? How did the institution of marriage -- and divorce -- operate in the early church? How did the presence of slaves affect domestic and public affairs? What attitudes did believers hold about their sexuality, body, masculinity or womanhood? Why was ascetic behavior so appealing to many, like Paul? What positions did men hold in congregations? What positions did women hold? Were some women empowered to lead early congregations? Why or why not?

This course seeks to answer these intellectually compelling questions using gender as a category of historical analysis. It takes the concept of gender to family and household experience. Yet this course also connects the concept to other social systems of economy, politics and power, such as slavery. Of particular interest is the role of women in early Christian domestic and political structure. The result yields a revealing look at the daily life of the earliest Christians and their appropriation of "pagan" morality and certain family values found in wider Greco-Roman society.

After an introductory review of the New Testament writings and of the concepts "family" and "gender," we will go in search of the Greco-Roman family. Topics include housing and city life, education and occupations, family relations and the law. We will then examine early Christian moral teachings in the context of Jewish and Greco-Roman popular morality, with special attention to a comparison of Pauline ethics and "pagan" ethics. We will seek to understand the early Christian family as a Greco-Roman family, focusing on slaves and children, marriage and divorce.

An examination of ancient gender constructions of masculinity and homosexual behavior is an integral component of this inquiry. We will then investigate the position of women in the early church, and the challenge of modern feminist theology in the modern church. In the last two weeks of class, the instructor will turn the class over to the students, who will give oral presentations of their research papers.

Required Texts

Dixon, S. (1992) The Roman Family. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN: 080184200X

Fiorenza, E.S. et al. (1994). In Memory of Her: A Feminist Theological Reconstruction of Christian Origins. New York: Crossroad/Herder & Herder. ISBN: 0824513576

HarperCollins Study Bible: New Revised Standard Version (with the Apocryphal/ Deuterocanonical Books), Wayne A. Meeks, et al., eds. (1993). New York: Society of Biblical Literature. ISBN: 0060655801

Osiek, C. and Balch, D. (1997). Families in the New Testament World: Households and House Churches. Louisville, KY: John Knox/ Westminster Press. ISBN: 0664255469

Williams, C.A. (2010). Roman Homosexuality: Ideologies of Masculinity in Classical Antiquity (Ideologies of Desire), 2nd Edition. New York: Oxford Press. ISBN: 978-0-538874-9

Women & Christian Origins, Ross Kraemer and Mary D'Angelo, eds, (1999). New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN: 978-0-19-510396-0

There are also online articles (in html and pdf formats). You will be expected to read the articles and take careful notes prior to the class period to which they are assigned.

Course Requirements

1. Students will keep a Reading/Reflection Journal. This journal should reflect 1) notes on reading, constructed prior to the class session for which the reading was assigned and 2) reflections on class lecture and discussion. Notes on reading should reflect an in-depth analysis of the selections for the day while reflections should be at least one page in length (minimum). Journals will be collected without notice four times during the semester. If you do not have your notebook in class when I request it, you will receive no credit. Notebooks must be up-to-date at time of submission. 100 points possible for each submission; 400 points total. ALL JOURNAL ENTRIES MUST BE TYPED; NO HAND-WRITTEN ENTRIES WILL BE ACCEPTED. JOURNAL ENTRIES MAY ALSO BE SUBMITTED FOR EACH CLASS PERIOD VIA EMAIL (dotto@centenary.edu) AS A WORD DOCUMENT (ACTUALLY THE BEST WAY TO KEEP UP WITH THIS ASSIGNMENT).

2. Wednesday, February 19 will be our MIDTERM EXAMINATION. Test shall consist of Fill-in-the-Blank, Identification of Term/Concept, short and long essay questions. 250 points possible.

3. RESEARCH PAPER (AND ORAL PRESENTATION). This is to be 15 pages, plus bibliography (1-2 pages). More on this later. Your paper grade will depend not only on the final written draft, but also the oral presentation in class. Due dates for this staged assignment found in the class schedule below. 900 points possible.

4. Final Exam, TBA, same format as Midterm Examination. Worth 250 points possibe.


Attendance Policy

I have been encouraged by THE POWERS THAT BE to express my assumptions regarding the topic.

First, I am not your parent, your brother, or your best friend; I am a colleague in both teaching and learning. We need each other for this classroom tribe to function.

Second, when you are not here, you will be missed. Our community will be diminished. Sure, most of us will miss a class. But what happens when somebody misses more than three class periods this semester?

As Convener of this Tribe, I will assume that you have found a new community that requires your presence. So, due to my desire to live a life of total compassion, I will deduct one letter grade from your final course grade for each additional class period missed, thus encouraging you to be wherever it is you need to be other than our class. I will make NO EXCEPTIONS TO THIS POLICY.

Inclusive Language

Within this course you are encouraged strongly to utilize "inclusive language". What does this term mean? When we speak of humanity, avoid using the gender specific term "man" as a synonym. When you speak of a particular god or goddess, use their proper name. Find ways in which to demonstrate respect and dignity for all persons, both believers and seekers.

Acceptance of Late Papers

It is a requirement of this course that you submit written work on time, that is in class the day a paper is due. A paper submitted after the end of class is late. Late papers will result in the loss of a one letter grade for every day (additional 24-hour period) after the due date (e.g., a paper with the grade of B will become a C if one day late, D if two days late, and so forth). A medical excuse does not exempt you from your responsibility to submit work on time. Assignments can be turned in at any time before the final deadline.

Internet Policy

While there is an increasing number of web pages devoted to the Bible and scholarly research, the information is often not reliable or better than what is available in the library book and journal collections. Therefore, you are not to use or cite any source from the Internet unless you have consulted with the professor (online databases excluded from this policy).

Writing Policy

All writing must reflect proper grammar and syntax. Failure to proofread and edit your work prior to submission (using The Writer's Cheat Sheet and the Paramedic Method) will result in a major grade reduction.

Submission of Work

All assignments are due at the beginning of class on the specified day. Late work will be accepted with letter-grade reduction per day penalty. Assignments more than four days late will not be accepted.

All written work (except the midterm exam) must be submitted via a Word document, sent to me via email (dotto@centenary.edu) as an attached Word document prior to the start of class. Do NOT paste text into the body of the email. I will confirm all papers received with a message saying that I received the paper and could open the file. This email functions as your receipt. A paper has not been turned in until I acknowledge it.

Office Hours and Making Appointments

Please schedule conferences to discuss work, problems, ideas or anything at all. I maintain an "open door" policy: if my door is open and you see a vacant chair, come on in. My office hours are 8:15 a.m. to 4:15 p.m., Monday through Friday, except when in class, a committee meeting or at lunch (12:00-12:50 p.m.). Check my website for my schedule.

Changes in the Syllabus

The syllabus can change at my discretion. Videos, readings and/or guest speakers may also be added. Changes will be make to the online syllabus.

What about some Extra Credit?

Extra credit does not exist in this course. Make use of the credit available.

Can I Receive an "A" for Effort?

"Trying hard" is usually necessary, but not sufficient, to create good work. In short, I do not base a grade on "effort" but on the finished product.

There is too much reading for this class!

I am well aware of the amount of reading for this course, but, given the subject matter, there is little choice. You are expected to come to class ready to discuss the reading assignment for that day. If you attend class ill-prepared, I will mark you as absent. Remember: three unexcused absenses can lead to significant consequences (see "Attendance Policy" for details). Further, I am aware that some of the material will be dense, requiring you to read it more than once. Plan your schedule accordingly. Are you a slow reader? Then plan in advance.

Scholastic Dishonesty & the Honor Court

As a student at Centenary College you agree to adhere to the Centenary Honor Code. I will carefully explain the nature of plagiarism the first day of class and, for each assignment, explain what is and is not permissable in terms of collaboration. If you have any questions, please ask rather than risk a problem. Also, I would advise you to retain all note cards, drafts, final papers etc. for each assignment in your writing record in case asked to prove your case. As explained in the Student Handbook, every assignment you submit must have the following statement written in your own handwriting accompanied by your signature: "I have neither given nor received unauthorized aid on this paper (or examination), nor have I seen anyone else do so." If you have received unauthorized aid or witnessed an honor code violation, you must follow the statement with: "...except as I shall report immediately to the Honor Court." Please understand that I cannot grade any assignment lacking this honor code statement. Please also read Chapter 16 in the St. Martin's Handbook (it is a book you should have kept from your FYE course).

Disability Accommodation

It is the policy of Centenary College to accommodate students with disabilities, pursuant to federal law, state law, and the College's commitment to equal educational opportunities. Any student who has a disability and needs accommodations, should inform the instructor at the beginning of the course. Students with disabilities need to contact Disability Services (a division of Counseling Services), which is located in the ground floor of Rotary Hall to obtain services. The phone numbers for Counseling Services are 869-5466 and 869-5424. Please let me know if you have any disability that requires accommodation. I will work with you to ensure your needs are met. Students with disabilities should also contact Disability Services (a division of Counseling Services), which is located in the ground floor of Rotary Hall to obtain services. Telephone 318-869-5466/5424.

Cellphone and Laptop Policy

Please turn off all cell phones upon entering class. Laptops may be used in class for the explicit purpose of taking notes. If you are caught surfing the Internet without permission (either on your phone or when and if we ever have Wi-Fi) or playing games you will not be allowed to bring the phone or laptop to class for the remainder of the course. Cell phones that ring can be ban from the classroom for the remainder of the semester.

Assignment Due
Points Possible
Reading/Reflection Journal (x 4)
400 Points
Paper topic Approved - JAN 27
50 points
Midterm Exam - Feb 19
250 points
Complete Bibliography -Feb 24
100 points
Rough Draft - March 28
250 points
Final Copy - April 9
100 points
Oral Presentation -April 16
200 points
Final Exam
TBA
250 points
TOTAL POINTS POSSIBLE
1500 POINTS

 

Class Schedule
BRING YOUR BIBLE TO EVERY CLASS
January 8 Introduction to Course
Review Syllabus and Assignments
 
January 10

Understanding the Concepts of "Family" and "Gender."
Read:
*Ehrman, New Testament, pp. 51-78. (pdf file)
*Joan Wallach Scott, Gender and the Politics of History, 28-50. (pdf file)

January 13

Feminist Theological Reconstruction (I)
Read:
Fiorenze, Introduction and Chapter 1

January 15 "Family, Gender and Feminist Reconstruction"
January 17 Feminist Theological Reconstruction (II)
Read:
Fiorenze, Chapter Two
January 20 MLK DAY - NO CLASS
January 22 The "Family Values" of Jesus (I)
Read:
The Gospels of Mark and Matthew
The Q Source (html link)
Secret Gospel of Mark (html link)
Gospel of Thomas (html link)
Osiek and Balch, pp. 123-155.
January 24 The "Family Values" of Jesus (II)
Read:
T he Gospels of Luke and John
Acts of the Apostles
2 Clement (html link)
Shepherd of Hermas (html link)
January 27 The World of Clement of Alexandria
Read for specific ideas of gender, sexuality and family life:
Clement's Stromata, Book III (html link)
Clement's The Instructor, Book I (html link)
Clement's The Instructor, Book II (html link)
PAPER TOPIC MUST BE APPROVED BY TODAY
January 29 In Search of the Greco-Roman Family (I)
Read:
Dixon, pp. 1-35
Osiek and Balch, pp. 5-47
January 31 In Search of the Greco-Roman Family (II)
Read:
Dixon, pp. 36-60
Osiek and Balch, pp. 48-102
February 3 Marriage and Celibacy
Read:
1 Corinthians
Osiek and Balch, pp. 103-118
February 5 Ancient Gynecologists: Galen and Soranus
Read:
Galen's Comparison of Male and Female Anatomy (html link)
Soranus on Conception, Abortion and Menstruation (html link)
Soranus on Childbirth (html link)
February 6

Roman Marriage and Laws (I)
Read:
Dixon, pp. 61-97
Digest, Books 23 and 24 (html link) To find the appropriate text:
Step One: Click on the link.
Step Two:On the left side of webpage, click on "Lingua Anglica"
Step Three: Scroll down on the right side of the page until you find "The Digest of Pandects"
Step Four: click on the word "Scott"
Step Five: Click on the appropriate book.
Latin Terms to know (pdf.file)

February 10 Roman Marriage and Laws (II)
Read:
Justinian Codes on Marriage and Adoption (html link)
Musonius Rufus Lectures (html link)
Plutarch and the Training of Children (html link)
The Twelve Tables (html link)
February 12 Playing House:
Gender Roles in the Early Christian Household
Read:
Ephesians, Colossians, 1 Timothy, 1 Peter
Osiek and Balch, pp. 118-123
 
February 14

Children, Education, and "Pagan" Moral Values (I)
Read:
Dixon, pp. 118-132

Osiek and Balch, pp. 156-173

February 17 Slaves and Family Life
Read:
Philemon; 1 Corinthians 7:20-24; Galatians 3:28; Ephesians 6:5-9; Colossians 3:22-4:1;
1 Timothy 6:1-2
Osiek and Balch, pp. 174-192
February 19 MIDTERM EXAMINATION
February 21 Life Cycle and Family Construction (I)
Read:
Dixon, pp. 133-163
Osiek and Balch, pp.
193-222 
February 24 Life Cylce and Family Construction (II)
Read:

Plutarch's Symposiacs (html link)
Philo's On the Contemplative Life (40-63) (html link)

BIBLIOGRAPHY DUE TODAY
February 26 Homosexuality in Ancient Rome (I)
Read:
Romans 1:18-32; 1 Corinthians 6:9
Dale Martin, "Arsenokoitês and Malakos: Meanings and Consequences," in Biblical Ethics and Homosexuality, ed. R. Brawley, pp. 117-136. (pdf file)
Bernadette J. Brooten, "Paul's Views on the Nature of Women and Female Homoeroticism," in Immaculate and Powerful, ed. C. Atkinson et al, pp. 61-87. (Word file)
February 28 Homosexuality in Ancient Rome (II)
Slaves, Prostitutes, Wives and the Appeal of Youth
Read:
Williams, pp. 3-66
"Greek Love in Rome" (pdf file)
March 3 SPRING BREAK
March 5 SPRING BREAK
March 7 SPRING BREAK
March 10

Homosexuality in Ancient Rome (III)
Read:
Williams, pp. 67-176

March 12 Effeminacy and Masculinity (IV)
Read:
Williams, pp.177-245
March 14 Sexual Roles and Identities (V)
Read:
Williams, pp. 160-224
March 17 Roman Same Sex Marriages (VI)
Read:
Williams, Read Conclusion, Afterward and Appendixes
The Passion of SS Serge and Bacchus (html link)
Same-Sex Union Ceremonies (html link)
March 19 Women and Christian Origins (I)
Read Kraemer and D'Angelo, Part One
March 21 Women and Christian Origins (II)
Read Kraemer and D'Angelo, Part Two
March 24 Women and Christian Origins (III)
Read Kraemer and D'Angelo, Part Three
March 26 Women and Christian Origins (IV)
Read Kraemer and D'Angelo, Part Four
March 28  Bisexuality and Early Christian Identity (I)
Wayne A. Meeks, "The Image of the Androgyne: Some Uses of a Symbol in Earliest Christianity," History of Religions 13 (1974): 165-208. (pdf file)
Acts of Paul and Thecla (html link)
Daniel Boyarin, A Radical Jew, pp.180-200 (with endnotes) (pdf file)
 
March 31 “Neither Male nor Female”:
Bisexuality and Early Christian Identity (II)
Read:
Galatians 3:26-28
Fiorenze, Chapter 6
ROUGH DRAFT DUE
April 2 Jesus Movements as Gender-Renewal Movements
Read:
Fiorenze, Chapter 4

SIGN UP FOR ORDER OF PRESENTATIONS
April 4 The Church in Her House
Read:
Fiorenze, Chapter 5
April 7 Patriarchy and Ministry
Read:
Fiorenze, Chapters 7-8
April 9 Gender and the Politics of Christian Conversion
Read:
”The ‘Attraction of Women’ in/to Early Judaism and Christianity" in Journal for the Study of the New Testament , No. 72 D 1998, p 5-22 (pdf file)
FINAL COPY OF RESEARCH PAPER DUE
April 11 Establishing the Rhetoric of Shame:
Sexual and Gender Reconfiguration
Read:
“Sex, Shame, and Rhetoric: En-Gendering Early Christian Ethics” in Journal of the American Academy of Religion 59 Sum 1991, p 221-245.
(pdf file)
April 14 "The Pracice and Prohibition of Self-Castration in Early Christianity" in Vigiliae Christianae, Vol. 51, No. 4 (Nov., 1997), pp. 396-41 (pdf file)
April 16 #1 Alissa Brown
Course Evaluation
April 18 EASTER BREAK
April 21 #1 Benjamin Green
#2 Claire Matthews
April 23 #1 Kayla King
#2 Meredith Ball
April 25

#1 Lexi Ross
#2 Angie Adame

TBA FINAL EXAM